Skip to content

Guidance for COI Review Due in Proposal Applications

Introduction

In accordance with Gold Standard Science principles, US Federal agencies and other sponsors are beginning to require mandatory COI review to identify conflicts of interest and conflicts of commitment prior to funding decisions. This information is often requested in the application.

These sponsors are known to require COI review in proposal applications:

(For assistance in obtaining IRB approval at the application stage, contact the IRB or review their “Concept Only Approval” Application Guidance.)

Process

Only for the sponsors listed above (and upon request from other sponsors) which have additional requirements for review at the proposal stage, please follow these steps to complete the mandatory review process.

This must occur prior to submission of your application to the agency, as additional reporting may be necessary depending on the outcome of the COI review.

A designated individual (any non-conflicted supervisor) must perform the initial COI review at the proposal stage. If you would like the COI Office to serve as the designated reviewer, please allow 5 business days for processing. 

1. INITIATE A FILING IN ePROPOSAL
Initiate a filing in eProposal to create a DSS tracking number. You do not need to complete the entire application in order for mandatory COI review to occur, but a DSS number is needed for tracking purposes. If you are unable to file in eProposal due to timeline restrictions, you may still proceed with this process to obtain COI review, but please provide your documentation to OSP.

2. FINALIZE THE LIST OF INVESTIGATORS
The Principal Investigator should confirm and validate the list of investigators within eProposal.

The University of Utah Individual Financial Conflict of Interest Policy 1-006 requires all individuals who are responsible for the design, conduct, or reporting of Research to be listed as an Investigator. The definition of Investigator may include additional roles depending on the project sponsor, so please review the COI Office’s Guidance for Identifying Investigators carefully.

2. COI TRAINING AND DISCLOSURE
All Investigators must complete COI training in the Business Relationship Reporting system.

All Investigators must submit a financial disclosure in the Business Relationship Reporting system dated within 12 months prior to proposal submission.

All Investigators must provide a copy of their most recent BRR financial disclosure (dated within 12 months) to the designated reviewer. To access a copy of your financial disclosure within BRR, go to 'Disclosure History' from the main dashboard, then click on your most recent disclosure and save it as a PDF. 

3. DESIGNATE A REVIEWER
The Principal Investigator should designate a non-conflicted supervisor (for example, an immediate supervisor, chair, dean, associate dean or vice dean) to perform an initial COI review for all Investigators. "Non-conflicted" means that the individual has no financial conflicts of interest or conflicts of commitment related to the project. You may also request that the COI Office serve as the designated reviewer (if so, please contact the COI Office to request a review and allow 5 business days for processing). Ideally, there would be only 1 designated reviewer for a project (it is allowable for a study team member to perform this role if they are a supervisor to the group and are non-conflicted).

4. CONSIDERING CONFLICTS OF INTEREST AND COMMITMENT
When conducting their review, the designated reviewer should consider the following elements for each Investigator:
 
Does the Investigator hold any Significant Financial Interests?
 
If no, then there is no potential conflict. Proceed to submit the assessment.
If yes, then are those interests directly and significantly related to the research?
 
If no, then there is no potential conflict. Proceed to submit the assessment.
If yes, then is the conflict related to a foriegn entity?
 
If yes, then contact the COI Office for assistance.
If no, then is this conflict managable? 
 
If no, then contact the COI Office for assistance.
If yes (usually the case), then determine what management plan strageties can be implmented to mitigate risk. 
 
5. DETERMINING A MANAGEMENT PLAN STRATEGY (IF NEEDED)
Refer to https://coi.utah.edu/management.php for examples of commonly used management plan strategies and determine what may be feasible for the project under review. 
 
6. DOCUMENT THE ASSESSMENT IN WRITING
The designated reviewer must document their assessment in writing. The preferred mechanism for this is by submiting this form [FORM LINK WILL GO LIVE SOON---until then, please email the assessment outcome to COI@utah.edu]. Upon completion of the assessment, the designated reviewer and the Principal Investigator will receive an email confirming receipt. Unless additional reporting to the sponsor is required, you may now proceed in submitting your proposal application to the sponsor.
 
7. OTHER ELEMENTS YOU MAY ENCOUNTER
Some agencies (for example, NSF) may ask for additional information related to 'Organizational Conflicts of Interest (OCI), which represent situations where an individual's service or work on behalf of a U.S. government agency or other funding sponsor may provide the Institution an unfair competitive advantage when others apply for a funding opportunity with that agency or sponsor.
 
Contact the COI Office for assistance if your application mentions this. Agencies define this term differently and could be seeking different forms of information, depending on the application.
 
8. ADDITIONAL REPORTING TO THE SPONSOR (IF APPLICABLE)
In the event that unmanageable or foreign conflicts of interest/commitment are identified, additional reporting to the sponsor in the application may be necessary. Contact the COI Office for assistance. 
 
* Centralized COI review and approval from the Individual Conflict of Interest Committee will occur upon further notice of award (prior to the Investigator engaging in research). The COI review outcome and management strategy may evolve over the course of the project. 
Last Updated: 8/20/26